first written 09.30.24 2203est
On September 11th 2024. From the Apples website's refurbished store front I purchased a M3 pro MacBook for roughly $1500. This was the most expensive single transaction I have had made in my life so far. embarrassing I know. I have never owned an Apple product before this. I was diving deep into a pool which in my circles was very unpopular.
I have had only touch an Apple device thrice before. When I was very young, I was forced to wander the campus of EDU while my dad worked. In the biology labs, one of the offices I frequented housed an iMac g4. I had pulled up the LEGO website on it, to play a LEGO Star Wars flash game. The lab second nearest to that office had an Apple PowerPC. It was hot and loud. Much louder than my dad's and I's PCs at home. It felt like a crude piece of machinery. I made it a point to never touch that PowerPC. I wasn't supposed to touch any of the lab computers, but that hadn't been a concern to my discretion.
In my 2nd year of middle school my school district was given a big flashy grant, that the admin made a constant big deal about. A large portion of that grant was spent buying a 2012 Mac book Air for each student. A decision by the staff, that confused me greatly at the time and only makes sense to me now if I am in my most cynical state of mind. Our school was quite ran down. Blinking fluorescent lights illuminated each sterile hallway. Our lunch table seats had been whittled down to only a little more than a pole. Our teachers were stretched thin and were of course poorly compensated.
But all the same I was issued a MacBook Air with a user profile that forbid me from touch files outside of the User folder. I could still run executables, but I couldn't install them into ~/Applications/. I liked it. When I first got it, the first thing I did was download a Game Grumps wallpaper. After leaving middle school, I didn't give much thought to that laptop. The subject of my ruminations during this part of my life was much about my new custom built PC and living with Linux permanently in my life.
In current day, I was lured into the possibility of buying a MacBook by two Youtubers who I respect for their level headed endorsements. First was Wolfgang's analysis of his M1 MacBook air vs his previous X1 Carbon (the laptop I used before ordering the M3). Secondly Livakivi's intricate anecdote of taking a risk on a M1 Max in the face of expensive prospective GPU prices and the need for a device that could be easily taken while moving to japan (Which funnily enough was the same spot I am in too).
I frequently checked the provided shipping information page. I would close it and have to find the email and pull it up again, this ritual usually occurred twice a day after each meal. While waiting I reviewed both of the previously mentioned videos thrice over and studied the complex and nuanced analysis by the ghouls on 4channel's /g/.
My conviction in this purchase was shaky. Even before it had been in my life, I was already of thinking about how to rid myself of it. Just compulsive and unstoppable stream of scrutiny and self doubt. A complex allotted to me by Apple's 14 day return policy. I could risk free, get my money back. As long as I could make up my mind by the end of that return period.
I was very certain on the outset that this laptop would be cleaned up and dropped off at the closest Apple store (a 40 minute drive) within the first 4 days of the return period. That day lined up on when I would be on my way to Magic: The Gathering tournament. But that day had come and passed.
It still sat on my desk in an erratic and way that did not convey stillness. This being the living testament of my inability to come to a decision on the value of having this burden follow me around. It had sprouted roots, and planted itself into my desk; into my time.
Pictured my M3 a few days into using it. It had adopted the form of an octopus with its wires splaying all across my desk.
I love the hardware; loathe the software.
The relation with Mac OS and this device can't be un-tangled. To get ahead of it, as a self described Linux advocate: I will not be a beta tester for Asahi Linux. Asahi Linux for those not familiar is the most developed distribution on Apple's ARM (Mx?) platform. As of writing Asahi is bootable on my device, but does not support many of the features. I do eagerly follow progress and I commit before publishing this post I will have contributed a small donation of $25 to Hector Martin via GitHub's sponsoring feature. If you're interested in using Asahi on your device and you haven't already I would encourage you to make a donation within your means.
My receipt of a one time $25 donation to Martin through Github's sponsorship page.
After kind of covering my ass, with my preface on why I am not using Linux on this device I would like to delve into everything I loathe about the software of Mac OS.
Mac OS as software
While certainly not required reading I would love to recommend the previously mentioned video by Livakivi on his experience with his M1 Max. In the video he catalogues the laundry list of issues he experienced as a power user transitioning to using Mac OS. I have almost entirely agreed with all of his assessments. So in an effort to avoid treading in already treaded ground and because I think a kind of bullet point list of grievances is a lazy form of writing. I want to approach my issues with Mac OS as a bigger picture issue and litter in a few concrete examples to ground it out.
Mac OS in many ways is defined in opposition to Windows instead of maybe a more natural delineation. Repeatedly while working on the device I would instinctively use some short cut (usually related to window management.) and it would of course not work. That's not inherently a problem but what is is that when I would look up Apple's solution they would either not exist or be touch/trackpad focused. I won't labor you with why its annoying, but the bottom line is that its not compatible with me.
The Case for Mac OS: a side note.
I think one of the better arguments in favor of using Mac OS is the credibility of apple in holding all of my sensitive information. ( >:O <-- probably you right now). This is a bit of a nuanced argument. If any private entity holding your information is a no go, I find that respectable. But I believe that of all the private companies Apple is probably my third most trusted to hold my data (The first and second being Mullvad and Signal. But if only for the reason that it has been proven in the courts that they don't hold any information on its' users :P ).
I think as described Mac OS being a very pointer focused OS is simultaneously an upside. Just given the context of the use. While at my desk getting work done, it infuriates me to no end the hoops I must jump through for simple navigation. But while lying on my bed where my hand is almost always resting on the track pad, I find it quite blissful. Which is almost to be expected because this is clearly the designed use case not just for Mac OS but all apple products. Which importantly is one of the conditions of using a laptop, so I find it often inappropriate to disregard the couch based accessibility of mobile devices.
The M3 Pro as hardware
Saying goodbye.
On the 24th of September, I sat with my macbook preparing it to be returned to my nearest apple store. Which required that I disconnect my Apple ID from it, an appreciated notion of good faith; though tedious. My last day to return it being the 27th, but I required to give myself time to prepare a suitable solution for a traveling computer so I moved in advance of that date.
My last screenshot taken on my MacBook before I sent it to the long sleep. ):
Through out my usage of this device I felt very tortured. But I feel like it's ultimately in the hands of the ARM platform. While undoubtedly has a bright future ahead in its current form it is burdened by a lot compromise. For a machine that I need to do work, I am not willing to compromise on a handful of features. For a machine that was supposed to replace my desktop.