first written 01.24.25 0113est. edited 04.08.25 1323est.
short preface: like most of my posts here, this is steeped in accounts of my past. the post itself is about scott pilgrim's little life and how it affected my dead end life. but it is about me foremost. which is to warn any readers seeking a more firm analysis about the comic that this is more of a vague meandering about my life as a dirt bag middle-schooler.
In my second year of middle-school when we were first issued MacBooks and I got that Game Grumps wallpaper is when I first read Scott Pilgrim. The comic had a lot of cultural access points into my mind. so I was familiar with many of the internet's screenshots of it, and I was aware that there was a movie the fans were then so-so about. Some people who would later say shit like "Bazinga" ironically would say it betrayed the original comic's vision. But all the same it was spoken as though it was something made for us teenager scum bags on the net. Because of that I imagined Scott to be a talent-less neet a la Watamote's Tomoko, which I had watched by that point on my Pikachu 3DS XL which I had earned for achieving the honor roll in my first year of middle school. I liked Scott's hair and his girlfriend's hair. I really wanted to wear my hair long for all my life until I turned 21. But my parent's perfectly normal hair cut schedule for dirt bag youth didn't permit me to grow it any longer than past my ears really.
There wasn't quite a fandom like there is now. Which isn't a comment about scope but more about the existing infrastructure. I am sure on 4channel's /co/ or some forum unknown to me there was discussion and community. But to my eyes Scott Pilgrim was just a thing casually mentioned in web comics and Youtube videos. A covert way to signal: you too were uncomfortable with women.
I sought out the fist volume on an aptly named website promoting free manga you could read in your damn browser. I read it on my dad's computer in his office. He wouldn't get home until 6:30pm -ish and I wouldn't get home from school until 3pm-ish, leaving me a cool 3 hours to use his computer. I had my own computer and even a laptop. But his computer played games better than either of mine. The irony is that most of my time spent on the device was just web browsing; something my laptop was perfectly capable of. When I finished that last page of volume I didn't really get it. I think I was more relieved to just say I had actually read it.
I was confronted with this kind skewed semi ironic tone of Canada. A place which I was familiar with only on a very surface level because I told my middle-school peers that I was born in Toronto. Basically my only friend at the time besides the girl I loved, was this kid named Mason. He was a liar. Like me. We both knew it, and we indulged each other, I'm not sure why. He made an auto biographical YouTube video for his channel that would be called Mason the Talented (though what it was called then is lost to me) in the video he discussed also being born and raised in Toronto. We talked extensively via the Wii U video chat app about how much we liked Toronto and also how much we wanted to make an RPG together. A cute dance where we would dip and catch each other if either of us dared to make a statement that could be retorted with any scrutiny.
Which is to say that Canada to me was not different from Scott Pilgrim's depiction; the non existing contrast put me on heels. Basically I could smell my own shit. I stuck with the comic because of its' cultural legacy alone. I read until the 2nd volume where after completing it my attention was sooner caught by Smash Brothers Melee. Some time later I watched the movie as an oh yeah something i read before kinda. I felt strangely ambivalent about it. It felt like something different, it felt like it wasn't for me. It felt like it was for guys who played guitar. Which maybe a more astute middle-schooler of the time would of correctly identified was also very true about the comic.
Sometime later, which I cannot say with high certainty but in this moment I feel like that time later was after I had given up that the girl would ever love me, is when I read scott pilgrim in its' entirety. Which I sourced from a blogspot blog in the form of a FTP download for a PDF of each volume. I read through it in chunks each night, but never at school to my memory even though I had that MacBook with me. When I read it, I read it in my then bed. Which was setup out of a closet. The closet was out of the strange contraption that was my bed, desk, closet thing. I had a normal mattress bed that had just been moved into my room a few weeks before but I chose to sleep in that closet. I am not sure specifically why I did. Basically it's because I wanted to feel like the shape of unloved and relegated to a closet like Harry Potter, or it could of been some other compulsion to be sealed in. But in that closet with my LEGO blanket (its' consisting of bricks that were blue, yellow, red, and green) and plastic blue lamp that projected a blue tint to everything in that closet, I opened myself up to Scott Pilgrim's sad little life.
I was captured. I am not sure if it was because I was finally more familiar with rejection or if more so being captured by the fear of rejection but It had finally lodged itself into me. The MacBook was held up by a pedestal of two books at the end of that closet and I would lay on my stomach with my elbows on the floor and my hands were a rest for my chin. It was rough on my elbows because the closet part wasn't sanded and was littered with uneven spikes of wood sticking out.
After I read it in middle-school I cannot recall reading Scott Pilgrim again. Though I did really enjoy the demo for the Xbox Live Arcade game. I did play through that demo 7 times. I credit Scott Pilgrim (the comic) with helping me get over the fact that she didn't love me. I am not sure why it helped me, it wasn't really an escape. I think maybe it was just like Scott had Romana: this girl who was sooooo cool but he also had that killer ass ex played by Bri Larson in the movie and I guess it just gave me perspective, and maybe even the confidence to believe I could love someone more than I loved this girl in middle school.
We often look down at how small our conflicts were in our childhood. But some perspective that can be lost on us now is that when we experienced loss as kids, that was often the most loss we have had ever felt at that point in our lives. Something as silly as a girl not liking you was maybe literally the worst thing that had happened to you yet.
bb